PROPOSAL WORKSHEET

Compare the scope.
Then compare the price.

Use this worksheet while reading two remodeling proposals. Record what each one actually says and identify the questions still worth asking.

Your selections stay in this page until you reload or leave. This is an organizational checklist, not a contractor rating, legal review or estimate.

Two proposals, the same questions
What to checkProposal AProposal B
Scope & quantitiesDo both proposals cover the same rooms, dimensions, preparation and installation work?
Materials & selectionsAre product specifications, quantities, suppliers and purchasing responsibilities clear?
AllowancesWhich items are provisional? Ask how an allowance changes when a selection is finalized.
Concealed conditionsHow will unexpected conditions be documented, priced and approved?
Approvals & inspectionsWho confirms applicable approvals, submits documents and coordinates inspections?
Protection & cleanupIs protection, access, debris removal and final cleanup described?
Schedule & dependenciesAre ordering, site access and inspections reflected in the proposed sequence?
Changes & paymentsAre the written change process and payment milestones explained?
Completion & follow-upWhat defines completion, and how are punch-list items and written warranty terms handled?

Proposal A: 9 items need clarification. Proposal B: 9 items need clarification.

An exclusion or allowance can be appropriate if you understand and accept it. More “defined” items alone do not identify the better contractor.

Turn the gaps
into useful questions.

Ask how an excluded item will be handled, what an allowance covers and what information is needed to replace a provisional number with a defined scope.

Call QPSText photosFree estimate ↗